Product Reviews
Fun Fit
Wore this to the office as a sort of “Valentine’s Day adjacent fit.” It was really cute. Fabric isn’t too warm, so it’s good for those kinda cold kinda warm days.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 3"
115 lbs
Athletic
34B
37 yrs
Cute!
Thick and warm, can be dressed up with a pair of trousers for work or down with jeans for a cozy winter look
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Size 0
5' 3"
115 lbs
Athletic
32B
31 yrs
Cozy cardi
This has been a staple for my winter wardrobe! I get lots of compliments because the pattern is so charming. Sleeves are a little short (and I have short arms) but that hasn’t stopped me from wearing it once a week!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 2"
130 lbs
Pear
34B
32 yrs
Loved it!
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Size 12
5' 10"
170 lbs
41 yrs
Loved it
Compliments all day. Just warm enough for the office.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Size 12
5' 2"
160 lbs
Hourglass
36C
50 yrs
Perfect
Easy to wear and was warm for a stroll around during a winter trip to Europe. Super soft! Really liked this one.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 9"
160 lbs
Athletic
36B
40 yrs
Sweet cardigan
Only pic I have is on a child. She loved it
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 2"
120 lbs
Athletic
34B
42 yrs
Adorable in floral
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 3"
135 lbs
Petite
34D
36 yrs
Cute and whimsical
This sweater feels lux and the details are great.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 4"
120 lbs
Athletic
34B
40 yrs
Cute “grandma” sweater
Exactly as advertised. Fits true to size. Good quality and warm.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 3"
125 lbs
Petite
34C
39 yrs
Festive grandma
The detailing on this cardigan give it a festive holiday look without being too literal. The M fit just how I wanted, skimming away from my body, and allowing buttons to close without tugging anywhere.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 4"
135 lbs
Athletic
32D
34 yrs
LOVE!
I love rails and this sweater did not disappoint. Super cute and got a lot of compliments wearing it
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 2"
120 lbs
Petite
34B
38 yrs
Short sleeves, lots of compliments
This sweater is really pretty. The sleeves were a little short for me, so I am glad I ordered a large. It has a bit of a boxy fit but not huge.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 10"
150 lbs
Athletic
36B
45 yrs
Beautiful quality and design
Was close to keeping this but the buy price was still a little high. Otherwise was considering it. I love that you can dress it up and down! I wore it to a thanksgiving lunch as well as every day for running errands. I sized up for a more modest fit.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 1"
122 lbs
31 yrs
So cute!
Got compliments on this. Definitely could have worn a medium instead.
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 4"
155 lbs
Full Bust
34DDD/E
38 yrs
Perfect Fall sweater
Came NWT and was so soft and so comfortable. I wore this sweater to dinner, shopping and all around - got lots of compliments I did size up to a Medium and glad I did, for the length.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 9"
130 lbs
Athletic
34C
56 yrs
Adorable Sweater
Wore to work with the some brown cords. I loooove sweaters and this fits just right. Is warm and not itchy! Took off the tags but will buy later when I can afford it!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 10"
150 lbs
Athletic
34DD
48 yrs
Unique everyday piece
Received several compliments. Comfortable, well made, medium weight sweater.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 3"
110 lbs
Hourglass
34D
60 yrs
Obsessed. Want to buy!
Love this fun, warm sweater. Fits loosely which is the right look for it, wouldn’t size down. Goes with everything!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 5"
150 lbs
Athletic
36C
38 yrs
Sooo Cute
Such a happy sweater. Someone stopped me in an airport to compliment me. Goes with everything. Loved it. Would buy if cheaper . Will keep my eye on it.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 2"
126 lbs
Apple
32DD
62 yrs
Cute
Nice sweater - fits true to size. I wore with the chocolate brown Madewell jeans.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 6"
129 lbs
Pear
34B
49 yrs
Waiting for a sale to buy!
Tip / fit: soft and warm, dress up or down. Review: ugh. Rails sweater of the season
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 2"
126 lbs
Hourglass
34B
34 yrs
Eh
This was much shorter than on the model - almost 3/4 length sleeves. I wonder if it was shrunk in the wash?
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Size 0
5' 3"
112 lbs
Petite
34A
37 yrs
Cute but a little itchy
Super cute and fit well. I wore a tank top under. Just a tad itchy for me. I got over it, but just putting it out there.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 10
Size 10
5' 4"
147 lbs
Petite
36B
38 yrs
Adorable cottage core
Fairly warm sweater, super cute pattern! I love the cottage core look
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 2"
125 lbs
Hourglass
34A
36 yrs
Scandinavian charm
This is such a cute sweater serving major Scandinavian charm! The sweater is a bit stiff (not scratchy, but not cozy either). Cute for a statement rental. I paired it with the Area Stars plaid skirt and brown kitten heels; really fun winter work day look!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 8"
150 lbs
Hourglass
36C
31 yrs
Cute
Cute sweater for the holidays. It’s a little bulky and heavy but cozy.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 4"
150 lbs
Hourglass
32DD
36 yrs
Cute sweater
Fun and diffferent. Very warm and versatile
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 3"
135 lbs
Athletic
38C
53 yrs
Pretty but wouldn’t rent again
This was not my favorite fit as it was a bit boxy and cropped. The design is really pretty though. I went with a large which is usually what I go with for sweaters. Also the sleeves didn’t even go to my wrists :( Wore to: work
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 6"
150 lbs
Hourglass
31 yrs
Fits TTS & warm
Arrived brand new and in perfect condition. Cute in a Scandinavian winter kind of way. Good fit and kept me warm, though wasn’t blown away by the look. Wore a long sleeve so it wouldn’t be itchy.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 9"
135 lbs
Straight & narrow
34A
45 yrs
Cute but not amazing
Easy enough to wear but somewhat disappointing
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 4"
126 lbs
Hourglass
34C
38 yrs
Rails Never Misses
Cute Cardi. - dress up or down, thick enough to stay warm and thin enough to wear under a jacket comfortably
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 4"
136 lbs
Pear
34C
41 yrs
Pretty but not favourite colors
This is very cute but I thought the colours would be brighter and more lively than they were. Loved the coral flowers but not as fond as the brown shades.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 3"
148 lbs
Hourglass
34D
49 yrs
So sweet
Very versatile! Got lots of compliments
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 4"
120 lbs
Hourglass
32B
32 yrs
Rent it!
TTS, so soft and warm. Goes well with everything!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 6"
Hourglass
41 yrs
Cute sweater!
Fit as expected! Super cute! More of an oatmeal color than a cream
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 10
Size 10
5' 6"
175 lbs
Hourglass
34B
27 yrs
Loved! Nonstop compliments
I might buy it. I wore to work with slacks as a sweater without a tank or shell. Can also dress down with jeans.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 5"
115 lbs
Hourglass
40 yrs
What you wish your grandma gave you
Awesome sweater. A little oversized but doesn't miss
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 4"
135 lbs
Pear
34A
43 yrs
SO Adorable! I got a ton of compliments on this!
It was true to size
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 14
Size 14
5' 6"
177 lbs
Apple
60 yrs
Fun sweater
Rails quality. Cute design. Got compliments on this sweater. May rent again. Fit true to size.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 2"
105 lbs
Petite
34C
63 yrs
1 - 40 of 149 reviews
