These were large on the waist. I could have gotten one size smaller.

I should have gotten a smaller size. They were a little big, but I was able to make them work. Loved the feel and trendy look. I would def rent again (just a size smaller)

These pants run big and are meant to hang. I got so many compliments! Recommend you size down.

Flexible, cute, and super flattering

Normally wear size 27; these are a little big in the waist, so they have a slouchy fit. I love the two-tone wide legs. Very comfortable. I get lots of compliments on these!

Comfy jeans! Rented twice!

these jeans are comfortable, lightweight,, and have some street, and fun to wear. The waist was a little big, but laid fine to wear.

I loved these pants! I wore them multiple times during the mo th for multiple events. I would suggest sizing up 2 sizes bc the hight waist is cut small.

I got my normal size and I was swimming in these. The belt ended up holding them up and I LOVE them very comfortable! I got a 31 and could have probably done a 29

Loved these though I had to cinch the waist by 8”! I am a true 30 size 10 and these measured 38”, I should’ve sized down by 1-2 instead of up. Will try again at 29 or 28 considering how large these wore. Also, these are probably best for 5’5” and below. Super soft and stretchy, great side view!

The next size up was too big across the board. This size fit perfectly in the waist but was the tiniest bit snug in the thighs. But they were so soft and comfortable, and I got lots of compliments!

Fabric was a but thin to consider trying a smaller size.

I wasn’t a fan of these. I didn’t think the shape was flattering and they were too short for my style and height. They felt like clown pants.

Made these work with a strong belt, but they fit weird. Too large in the waist, especially as high waisted jeans. Too short for someone my height.

Don’t be an idiot like me, please heed the advice to size down! I’m a very consistent size 31 in madewell and somehow thought I would be an exemption to this? But everyone was right and within an hour I could’ve easily just pulled them off without unbuttoning. Which is a shame because I loved the style of them! Very soft and comfortable. Just comically large

I wanted to love these and in my first shipment I got a 29 which is normally my size but after you wear them for an hour, they were falling off of me. So in my next shipment, I got the 28 which was tight at first and with an hour it was a perfect fit. However I just feel like Kris Kross from the 90s. Just not my jam

Perfect jean in a hot summer, thin and flows denim. Like a trouser over a jean. Came with tags! I will size down next time I rent.

These jeans were the perfect fit and style, not to wide leg and perfect around the waist. A bit long on me but almost perfect!

It's super confy and soft. Fits great! Got so many compliments. I ended up buying it a size smaller directly from Madewell!!

These pants were so fun! I was able to wear them with sneakers and they were the perfect length to just barely skim the floor

I sized down and re-ordered.

These jeans were truly the most comfortable low-waist jeans I have ever worn. Definitely a baggy fit, so I am going to re-rent a smaller size before purchasing to see how those fit better. However, the bagginess is definitely in-style. My 8th graders were hyping me up when I wore these. Paired with the "Toccin Estelle Crochet Racer Tank" as well as cropped cami-tanks, and big Ts. I basically lived in these jeans for the 2 months I had them.

Loved these jeans. Cute and comfy. The size chart but confusing so I went "up" a size to align with what I usually wear but this was a mistake in the end. Should have kept to my normal size! b

I first rented these in my regular size, but had to return and size down because they were just too baggy

These were awesome! Baggy but still enough structure to look put together. Also loved the “Swing” of these

These were big in the waist and actually a bit short on me (not a huge shocker). But, I loved them sooo much that I didn’t care. They’re flowy and soft. So stylish though very casual.

Super soft & comfy denim. Strongly considering buying — so so cute & fun! Generous fit w/ stretch.

I wore these a ton! They were so comfortable and I received a lot of compliments. I probably would have bought them but they run a little large so I'd prefer a smaller size. They were too long on me but I'm 5 foot so that was no surprise.

I wear madewell jeans almost exclusively. I always get size 27 and they fit perfectly. These fit *slightly* looser than other styles in the same size, but they were so comfy and soft. Great for a casual day and makes me feel nostalgic for the days of jncos.

These are so cute and flattering. I will say that they do run large. I’m usually a 26 in Madewell and these were a little too big. Probably could have had a better fit with a size 25.

Can run slightly large, but super comfortable even on a hot day. I wore these jeans several times and considered buying them.

These pants have amazing stretch. I went a size down because I ordered my original size and by the end of the day they had doubled on my waist, but I re-ordered a size down and they fit perfect and I’m buying them.

A little loose. Maybe would have gone down a size. But I loved them!

I had to wear a belt to hold these up! I love these pants though and rented them again in a smaller size. Lightweight and fun!

Size down, I needed a 25

Perfect barrel loose jeans. So soft.