I rented in a small and then again in XS. Both worked fine. Preferred the XS. The knit part hit below the widest part of my hips and I didn’t have any issues with the skirt being tight there. The silk portion doesn’t stretch, but was only an issue if I had to take a really wide step or something.

It was fine - didn’t love it or hate it but high quality and good for work. A bit tight on hips and baggy on top so not great for pears

After reading the reviews and pondering, I added it to my bag! I know, I know, but I LOVED the look!! Yes, the neck hole IS small - I got my puffy hair and head through it! YES, the hips are narrow with no give, but - IF you get it right, this IS a good dress!!! So I’m losing weight and I’m all over the map with sizes right now. I went with a medium knowing it might be a flop/wasted spot rental - but it worked for the day at school and I got so many compliments!! Even with hip, I definitely am curvy, I made this work for the day! It was worth the risk for me.

Love the look of the casual sweatshirt top over a the silk skirt. Warning - if you have a big head this will be almost impossible to slip over! Very small opening. Sleeves are also very long. Still fun and glad i rented!

Loved the concept and colors, but the dress itself was just okay — not a home run. It’s cozy, but the sweatshirt-like fabric hangs a little too low on my frame and feels boxy. Sleeves were long, so I had to fold the cuffs. I knew it wasn’t a winner when my boots got all the compliments during hospital rounds and no one mentioned the dress!

Comfy, great color and bonus...looks like two pieces!

Wore it several times! Maybe I have a small neck and head(?) but I was not bothered by the tighter neck and the fit was fantastic! Compliments galore, and such an easy comfortable outfit

The xtra large fit my size 14 body.

Cute for lunch w friends.

Great pattern and color combo.

I love everything from this brand. It was a little tight in the waist and big in shoulders, but was still great for work with boots.

Sweatshirt doesn't have much stretch so getting right size is key

Cute and comfortable- but the reviews mentioning the tight head hole were NOT exaggerating. Definitely get it on before you apply makeup or put in earrings!

I’m not sure what the other reviews are saying about the fit but I’m 5’10 115 pounds and a small was absolutely perfect on me. It’s so cute and comfortable. Effortlessly chic

Pencil skirt is fitted in the hips. Sweatshirt top is tailored. It is a little hard to pull on, but definitely fun to wear! I rented a large instead of my usual medium.

Mixed textile, super comfy, will be renting again!

Easy to wear comfortable

Medium fit me but if you want it to be oversized, order a size bigger

The skirt fabric was gorgeous but it does nothing for your figure. For being a sweatshirt with fabric attached it isn't diver constable- but that it was uncomfortable I just expected a sorry cozy winter dress. I would still recommend it, just know what you're getting.

If this were separates, I’d be buying it. The colorway is wonderful and the fabric is top quality. Overall, it is both comfortable and chic. I just don’t like that the skirt is attached to what amounts to a sweatshirt that cannot be tucked or styled in any way. I used a skinny belt to fein a tuck, and added a brown velvet blazer. Still a win for quality, and color!

Pretty skirt but interesting sweatshirt material on top.

This was cool and fit really well. Only 4 of 5 stars because it's prime to static cling which makes the silk skirt really stick to all the wrong places

If you have a bigger butt size up but also arms will be too long.

Not made for anyone with an apple shape. The sweatshirt was heavy but the skirt was thin so it was odd to wear weather wise too.

Cute dress but the neck is so high cut I never wore it

Was ok, wouldn't get again.

A little bit awkward. Dropwaist.

Had to style it with a belt to make it look flattering. Cool concept but not sure I would rent again.

The top part was too loose and long, and the neck was too high. The skirt part was too tight with no stretch. Pretty colors, though!

The quality of this was super nice. It came with tags attached. I am 5‘5“ tall, 210 pounds and couldn’t slide the skirt down over my hips.

Odd fit. Bottom is narrow and hard to walk in.