3.5
136 Reviews

Includes written reviews and customer fit feedback.

Most members say this item
Runs True to Size
Fit Summary
Runs Small (14)
True to Size (48)
Runs Large (4)
Member Photos (0)

Loved!

Got engaged in this dress! Thick material to perfect for fall/ colder months

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2

Usual Size: 0


SarahTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 6"

125 lbs

Straight & narrow

26 yrs

Browse Sarah's reviews (1)

Hunter bell fall dress perfection

The dress has a thicker quilted material making it great for fall! The sleeve holes are a bit tight, but it helps with the ballooning. I’m 3 mo post partum and have a fuller chest so I sized up, but I’d say it runs TTS

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 12

Usual Size: 8


JackiIncentivized

Size 8

5' 3"

Athletic

36D

32 yrs

Browse Jacki's reviews (130)

Perfect fit

The only slightly annoying this is that the arms have no elastic so they can be a little tight if you’ve got big muscles!!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 0

Usual Size: 0


BaileeTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 0"

120 lbs

Athletic

32C

28 yrs

Browse Bailee's reviews (78)

Loved! So many complements

Overall it's comfortable and fits true to size but the arms are very tight. I would size up if I got it again simply for that

Size Worn: 2

Usual Size: 2


AinsleyTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 6"

125 lbs

Athletic

34B

30 yrs

Browse Ainsley's reviews (33)

Arms were a little tight

Be prepared for endless compliments. Comfortable and one of my favorite rentals.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 8

Usual Size: 8


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 8"

148 lbs

Pear

47 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (6)

Cute, comfy little dress

This was such an easy dress to throw on for a baby shower. Really comfortable and honestly snuggly because it’s made from a quilted material. Some reviews said the arm holes were too tight—which they are somewhat snug—but I think that’s necessary to keep the shape of the sleeves. They weren’t tight enough to hinder the wearing experience.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 8


ArevTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 1"

130 lbs

Hourglass

34B

32 yrs

Browse Arev's reviews (46)

Beautiful dress

Beautiful dress! The structure of the top made it very flattering. My husband told me I looked like I was going to an Amish convention 🤦🏻‍♀️ I agree with others that it’s somewhat matronly but I liked it. The sleeves were a little tight on my arms but it looked fine/wasn’t a problem. Great fit for petite ladies

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 0

Usual Size: 0


ShelleyTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 1"

112 lbs

Athletic

32C

38 yrs

Browse Shelley's reviews (4)

Fun dress!

Great colors and pattern. The sleeves were a bit tight on the arms. The quilting is medium weight so it could be worn in cooler weather.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 10

Usual Size: 14


EmilyTop Contributor

Size 14

5' 11"

195 lbs

Hourglass

34A

32 yrs

Browse Emily's reviews (59)

Love

Received lots of compliments when wearing this dress! The color of cobalt blue on the piping is a stunning color. The cuffs on the sleeves were extremely tight—so keep that in mind if your arms are a bit large. I have average size biceps and the cuff left an indention on my skin!

Size Worn: 4

Usual Size: 6


MollieTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 6"

153 lbs

Pear

34B

47 yrs

Browse Mollie's reviews (24)

Churning butter but make it cute.

I loved the feel of this. Like a quilt almost. It was super cute and not overly warm. The top has some structure to it which I loved.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 6


MariaIncentivized

Size 6

5' 3"

130 lbs

Hourglass

34B

31 yrs

Browse Maria's reviews (21)

Perfect Fall Dress

was surprised I loved this as much as I did! Wore for work as well as weekends and church events. Super versatile! Thicker fabric than I thought.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 8

Usual Size: 6


ArieanaTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 10"

145 lbs

Hourglass

34B

27 yrs

Browse Arieana's reviews (37)

Fun dress

Cute & fun dress! The shoulders are a bit too balloon style for my liking it overall loved the dress and the quilted style made it easy to wear without a jacket

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 4

Usual Size: 4


MargaretIncentivized

Size 4

5' 4"

135 lbs

Athletic

34B

30 yrs

Browse Margaret's reviews (25)

Another Hunter Bell Gem

I love Hunter Bell. Their prints are unique and the pieces are high quality. I always size down in HB. Wore this with Mary Jane flats but would look great with boots, too! Follow @mgm_styles on instagram for more RTR reviews!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2

Usual Size: 4


MargaretIncentivized

Size 4

5' 4"

138 lbs

Athletic

34C

34 yrs

Browse Margaret's reviews (264)

Great fall dress

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 0

Usual Size: 0


Kacy Top Contributor

Size 0

5' 4"

120 lbs

Athletic

32A

41 yrs

Browse Kacy 's reviews (8)

Great print and quilted look!

As other reviews have stated, the sleeves were a bit tight for me. There is no button and they aren’t adjustable. Other than that, fit was great and quilted portions of the dress are a great touch!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 4


MeghanIncentivized

Size 4

5' 3"

135 lbs

Petite

32A

40 yrs

Browse Meghan's reviews (33)

Prairie vibes

But cute! The fabric is like a quilt. The sleeves are poofy and oversized. Would rent again.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 12

Usual Size: 12


RebeccaTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 5"

168 lbs

Apple

32DDD/E

38 yrs

Browse Rebecca's reviews (9)

Arm holes a little small otherwise wish I kept

LOVEE

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2

Usual Size: 2


GeorgiaIncentivized

Size 2

5' 4"

125 lbs

Petite

32D

25 yrs

Browse Georgia's reviews (11)

So much better in person

This dress looked even better in person than on the screen. So excited to have gotten a chance to rent this. Material is amazing with a thick quilt top. The arms on the dress isn't too tight like other reviews said. Current weight is 134lbs and size 6. I would say take your normal size.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 6


MishaIncentivized

Size 6

5' 6"

136 lbs

Hourglass

36C

38 yrs

Browse Misha's reviews (27)

Fun and a little silly

As others have said- the elastic on the arms is tight (you’ll have marks on your arms after wearing), and the way the sleeves are attached to the bodice is odd- very constricting. Outside of that, I loved this dress. A little ridiculous prairie / quilt like, but what a fun rental. High quality, fun for a dinner out.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 10

Usual Size: 8


MarthaTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 11"

Hourglass

32DDD/E

35 yrs

Browse Martha's reviews (439)

Fit is a little funky, but a good rental

The arms are a little tight and the way they are connected to the body of the dress is a little weird. As the day went on, it got a little tight in the ribcage. I probably could have worn a size up and been fine.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 8

Usual Size: 8


KatieTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 10"

150 lbs

Athletic

36B

45 yrs

Browse Katie's reviews (313)

Tight arms!

This dress would have been perfect despite the arm holes. I still wore it because it was super cute!

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: 4

Usual Size: 4


LaurenTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 3"

125 lbs

Petite

36 yrs

Browse Lauren's reviews (15)

Great fall dress

Sleeves are a little tight - well made and classic hunter bell.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size
Just right in Chest
small in Arms & Shoulders
Just right in Waist
Just right in Hips
Just right in Length

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 6


AnneIncentivized

Size 6

5' 3"

140 lbs

Pear

31 yrs

Browse Anne's reviews (97)

sleeves are very tight around the arms and you can’t lift arms all the way up

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 6


AndieTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 5"

141 lbs

Hourglass

24 yrs

Browse Andie's reviews (9)

Didn’t think I would like it on as much as I did!

So when it arrived I thought, crap, this is super “little house on the prairie” and tried it on and we like “eh” but when I styled it, I thought it was pretty cute! Lots of compliments! Warning- I am pretty thin and the arm ribbing, it pretty tight around my bicep. Maybe size up?:). Everything else fits perfect so hard to say it is “too small” but wanted to write a note!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2

Usual Size: 2


Christie Top Contributor

Size 2

5' 4"

120 lbs

Hourglass

34DD

50 yrs

Browse Christie 's reviews (6)

Comfortable but conservative

My coworkers joked that it made me look Amish. Super conservative length and coverage. Nice fit in the bodice but the arm holes, like other reviews, were super tight despite sizing up.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: 12

Usual Size: 10


EmmaTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 2"

160 lbs

Petite

36DD

32 yrs

Browse Emma's reviews (14)

It’s a Vibe

I did not hate it but I felt like I could have sized down so that it was fitted up top. It was somewhat big for me and it is thick.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 4


KristenTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 5"

140 lbs

Hourglass

32C

31 yrs

Browse Kristen's reviews (11)

Cute but very conservative

I like it but it's very "buttoned up" if that's not your style. Thick quilted fabric

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 8

Usual Size: 6


EmilyIncentivized

Size 6

5' 3"

130 lbs

Hourglass

32DD

34 yrs

Browse Emily's reviews (75)

Quilted and sweet!

Great dress for fall. It’s quilted in the arms and a wide band at the hem. Comes off a little prairie girl, but got so many compliments. The arms are TIGHT though. I kept adjusting them to try to relieve some pain. Overall, very cute.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 8

Usual Size: 6


LaurenIncentivized

Size 6

5' 5"

150 lbs

Hourglass

36C

37 yrs

Browse Lauren's reviews (65)

Could not wear, not too sad about it

The dress is an actual quilt - cozy? Also gives dollbaby vibes. I would've worn it once but the sleeve cuff was too tight, and bc of the piping, painfully cut into my upper arm.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: 10

Usual Size: 10


KelleyTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 9"

175 lbs

Athletic

38A

43 yrs

Browse Kelley's reviews (89)

This is a quilt

Literally quilt material, it felt very matronly on, did not work for my body.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 4

Usual Size: 4


ChrissyIncentivized

Size 4

5' 5"

120 lbs

Hourglass

32C

37 yrs

Browse Chrissy's reviews (165)

Team RTR Review

TINY TINY arm holes, i can’t imagine whose arms would comfortably fit. put on to get ready and had to change, couldn’t wear. shame because the rest of the dress is perfect.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: 12

Usual Size: 12


KaraIncentivized

Size 12

6' 0"

175 lbs

Hourglass

36D

34 yrs

Browse Kara's reviews (150)

Life Size American Girl Doll

I wanted to love this dress so much because I’m obsessed with the pattern and the touch of blue on the buttons and bodice but unfortunately the quilted fabric just left me feeling puffy and pilgrim-ish. Maybe sizing down would have helped with some of the largeness of the sleeves and bottom of the skirt (which held its shape in a puff due to the quilt texture) but like everyone else said the sleeves are very tight even with a roomier size so wearing my TTS fit would have been like a blood pressure test. Again, wanted to love this, maybe it’s better in the smaller sizes but it overall just left me feeling like the Samantha Parkington

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 4


CassidyTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 4"

140 lbs

Hourglass

32B

28 yrs

Browse Cassidy's reviews (5)

Great casual dress

Fit was great and beautifully made. I wore at home for a casual day with friends and family. It's a perfect effortless dress that looked polished and felt comfortable to wear all day!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size
Just right in Chest
Just right in Arms & Shoulders
Just right in Waist
Just right in Hips
Just right in Length

Size Worn: 2

Usual Size: 2


KaitlindTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 4"

115 lbs

41 yrs

Browse Kaitlind's reviews (2)

Obsessed.

It's was a beautiful thick material. It was a little tight on my arms at first but I generally loved it

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 4

Usual Size: 4


GretchenTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 6"

142 lbs

Hourglass

32C

43 yrs

Browse Gretchen's reviews (6)

Fun and cozy dress

I went with a size 4 but the arms were tight, would’ve gone up a size next time. It was perfect for a fun family event in the winter. The heavier fabric kept me warm and fitted well at the top. Very well made dress

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: 4

Usual Size: 4


ChristineTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 6"

135 lbs

Hourglass

32B

37 yrs

Browse Christine's reviews (2)

Tight arms

Loved this dress, super cute. Downside is the arms are very tight.

Size Worn: 8

Usual Size: 4


CarolineTop Contributor

Size 4

4' 11"

135 lbs

Hourglass

32DD

31 yrs

Browse Caroline's reviews (2)

Best winter dress

Received more compliments and questions as to where this dress came from than any other worn in a longgggg time. So pleased!

Size Worn: 0

Usual Size: 0


MaryTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 5"

111 lbs

Petite

32C

33 yrs

Browse Mary's reviews (10)

Beautiful dress with quilt material

It's a thick material with no give so TTS

Size Worn: 8

Usual Size: 10


JosephineTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 3"

155 lbs

Pear

34DDD/E

29 yrs

Browse Josephine's reviews (4)

Loved it!

I really loved this dress. I was able to wear this several times in December, and I would rent it again.

Size Worn: 6

Usual Size: 6


RayTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 2"

136 lbs

Petite

32DDD/E

46 yrs

Browse Ray's reviews (4)

Love!!!

Fit TTS! Love renting anything Hunter bell. The puff sleeves are perfect!

Size Worn: 4

Usual Size: 4


MargaretTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 4"

125 lbs

Straight & narrow

32B

23 yrs

Browse Margaret's reviews (8)

1 - 40 of 136 reviews

Here to brighten up your inbox.

Emails are the fastest way to learn about new styles, sales, and more.

By clicking submit, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.