Okay - I have decided that the key to this coat is to size up! It looks way cuter oversized, in my opinion, than the true to size look. I originally rented my typical size (XS) and it didn't fit the way I wanted. I tried again and rented two sizes up to a M and love the way it fits! It is seriously so comfy - like an outdoor bathrobe (But in a cool way)!

I thought it would be a jacket but it is fluffy and feels more like a coat, and too warm for fall weather in my opinion. Luckily, it is getting colder so I get to wear it. I got a size medium, although I normally like to wear a large, but it fits fine.

Strange fit with so much fabric on the collar. It’s puffer material which I didn’t realize when I picked it. I got it in a large and might have better in a medium. Probably best on someone very thin. In the photo, I’ve got a long sleeve shirt and thin pullover on under the coat. Looked a little better without the pullover but still unflattering. Can’t wear it open due to so much material with the wraparound. I won’t wear this coat.

This jacket is much thicker than expected and too thick to be a wrap coat. There is no closure, so you are relying just on the belt to keep it closed. It adds so much bulk as weight. It fit large in the chest and body, but the top and front of the shoulders were oddly tight, making it difficult to lift my arms. It’s just a no all around…

Didn't wear but fit well and was warm

I wish I had a picture of this. It looks so chic when you wear a mini skirt and boots. While the jacket is warm, you do have to constantly re-belt it since the top portion doesn’t close fully. Annoying but if it’s not too cold out then it’s fine.

Looks great & perfect for everyday wear

It doesn't stay closed very well so I wore a scarf to cover my chest. It was very warm!

Fit great but the collar is super bulky.

Very warm jacket. The pockets sit a little far back which made it a little odd and less functional but overall nice and glad I rented

It fit fine...didn't make you look the skinniest

Reminded me of the kid in The Christmas Stories who had so much coat he couldn't move his arms.

Fit is a bit shoulder heavy

I have broader shoulders and this was sadly slightly off for me bc I went TTS. I felt like I couldn’t fully extend my arms, but the length was great. If you have broader shoulders like me, maybe size up. I will rent this again just in a bigger size

Very unflattering for me. So puffy around the waist

In the XL size I felt like I was wearing a marshmallow.

Strange fitting jacket. Needs at least one button closure but had none.

It’s warm, but the only thing that closes it is the belt, so it let lots of cold air in at arms( too wide and to short) and at the neck.

I thought I was getting a sleek transitional rain, jacket, but what I ended up getting was a big puffy thick winter coat. This might be flattering on you if you are average to petite, but on my size 14 frame, it looked absolutely ridiculous. I just couldn’t deal with looking like a big black fluffy marshmallow. Too bad, I was hoping to look sleek in this on a business trip in rainy Seattle. Just know what you’re getting into, and if you have a frame that can accommodate a coat with some bulk.