Ratings & Reviews

(240)

Includes written reviews and customer fit feedback.

Runs Small
True to Size
Runs Large
RTR Member
I was worried about the peekaboo sides but I LOVED them! Such a beautiful color too!
September 8th, 2017
RTR Member
Size worn:
8
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
6
The dress does run small. I got a size 6 and I'm glad I got a back up size 8 or I wouldn't have been able to wear it. It fits tight in the stomach section.
Browse RTR Member's reviews
RTR Member
Perfect for my daughters first homecoming!
October 2nd, 2022
RTR Member
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Formal Affair
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 4"
Bust:
32C
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
110lbs
Browse RTR Member's reviews
Audrey
Super cute simple dress
August 13th, 2022
Audrey
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Other
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 6"
Bust:
34C
Body type:
Straight & narrow
Weight:
110lbs
I rented this for my freshman homecoming. Was very flattering and fitting on my wait. It is a simple dress yet super cute and unique. The color is not a normal blue it's super unique and fashionable. Pair with a necklace and it is perfect. I was afraid it wouldn't fit me as a small growing kid but the sizes are true to size.
Browse Audrey's reviews
Tasha
Great simple, youthful style
June 15th, 2022
Tasha
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Other
Usual size:
0
Height:
5' 3"
Bust:
32A
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
105lbs
I rented for my daughter's school promotion ceremony. It fit her well and was the "younger" style she was looking for. Definitely runs small so size up 1-2 sizes! She paired with Doc Martens since dress shoes are not her look.
Browse Tasha's reviews
Kristin
Great dress, lots of compliments! Would definitely wear again!
April 27th, 2022
Kristin
Size worn:
8
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
6
Height:
5' 7"
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
147lbs
Browse Kristin's reviews
Hailey
Great color and super cute cut outs
March 3rd, 2022
Hailey
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
30C
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
105lbs
This dress was very comfortable and made of a nice thick fabric. The cut outs have it that extra pop to make it a unique and exciting rental. I'd wear it again!
Browse Hailey's reviews
Kristen
High quality dress
July 22nd, 2021
Kristen
Size worn:
10
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
8
Height:
5' 7"
Bust:
36B
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
155lbs
This dress felt so nice! It was well constructed but not too hot for a summer wedding. Everyone says this and they mean it - SIZE UP! I wish I had got the 10 with 12 as a back-up size instead of an 8 with 10 as the back-up size. The dress isn't too tight elsewhere, but with the cutouts if it's even a little snug you might squeeze out a bit more than desired.
Browse Kristen's reviews
Deanna
Perfect graduation dress
June 2nd, 2021
Deanna
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Other
Usual size:
10
Height:
5' 8"
Bust:
36G
Body type:
Full Bust
Weight:
190lbs
I rented this for my daughter's 6th grade graduation. She really loved it and received many compliments from her classmates and other parents.
Browse Deanna's reviews
Bailey
LOVED THIS DRESS
May 27th, 2021
Bailey
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 0"
Bust:
32B
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
130lbs
This dress was my backup dress when I ordered it but I LOVED how it looked on me! I have always been a fan of skater-style dresses and the cuts in the sides give it just enough “sexy” factor to show off your figure without being too much. My date had to help me zip up the back as it was a tad too tight for me to get on my own but I could breathe in it and felt very comfortable wearing the dress for 6 hours. Wore it for an outdoor spring wedding, and danced all night in it afterwards. The material is thick and dark and held up well with a light sprinkle during the ceremony. I did not wear a bra with this dress, but easily could have.
Browse Bailey's reviews
RTR Member
Beautiful dark teal color!
September 16th, 2020
RTR Member
Size worn:
10
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
8
Height:
5' 9"
Bust:
36B
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
160lbs
I normally wear 6/8. After reading the reviews I decided to order the 8 and 10 as a backup. I'm glad I did, the 10 was perfect. I'm about 5'9 (without heels) - I was slightly worried about it being too short but the length was good. It was on the shorter side, but I didn't have any issues with it being too short. If you're taller, just something to consider! Overall 10 out of 10 on this one. I'll be back! :)
Browse RTR Member's reviews
Kristen
Perfect fall color
October 11th, 2022
Kristen
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 4"
Bust:
34DD
Body type:
Athletic
I wore this dress to a wedding. I paired it with black booties and accessories. The chest was a tad snug so I didn’t wear a bra. Loved the cut and would order again.
Browse Kristen's reviews
Lindsey
Great Dress
July 20th, 2022
Lindsey
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 8"
Bust:
34B
Body type:
Straight & narrow
Weight:
125lbs
As a lot of reviewers have noted, it's a little tight around the rib cage. It wasn't the most comfortable dress I've ever worn, but I loved it so much I powered through. It's pretty short, but I wore bike shorts underneath so it wasn't an issue. I also wore an adhesive bra, but you could just as easily use fashion tape to adhere bra cups to the inside (this would probably not work if I had actual boobs). I received several compliments and felt great in it (albeit slightly compressed). I recommend this dress, but size up if available!
Browse Lindsey's reviews
Monica
Runs small & short!
August 25th, 2021
Monica
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
0
Height:
5' 10"
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
125lbs
I'm 5'10" so the dress was a little short and it runs small--I had used a size 0 in this brand before but I would have preferred a size 2 on this style. Overall it was fine and I loved the color/style/material
Browse Monica's reviews
Elle
Love the color!!
September 22nd, 2017
Elle
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 3"
Bust:
38B
Body type:
Straight & narrow
Weight:
123lbs
Runs small and the hem was wonky BUT I wore it anyway! I loved the color and the way the dress flared out. The material is thick and a bra was not needed. I'm normally a zero or a double zero, but the zero didn't fit and thank God I had the back up of size 2.
Browse Elle's reviews
Alex
If you have a tummy, beware!
May 21st, 2021
Alex
Size worn:
NONE
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 0"
Bust:
32A
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
128lbs
Such a pretty dress but VERY small. If you don't have a totally flat stomach - or are self conscious about yours - this probably won't work. I don't have a 6 pack but I'm not in terrible shape, but my sides hung out of the cutouts of this a LOT. I don't love sharing this photo here but wish I had seen this before I ordered! I'm also 5 feet tall - you can see it is pretty short on me. Could be great for a sorority formal or a younger crowd but felt it would be too short for a rehearsal dinner.
Browse Alex's reviews
Brit
Emerald moment!
October 28th, 2019
Brit
Size worn:
4
Rented for:
Formal Affair
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 7"
Bust:
32A
Body type:
Straight & narrow
Weight:
138lbs
Rented for a college formal. It's very youthful, which I loved. It runs true to size, but size up to the larger size that you normally go with
Browse Brit's reviews
Kristin
Rented for Party, But Worn To Dinner & Las Vegas Show
October 17th, 2019
Kristin
Size worn:
6
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 7"
Bust:
34B
Body type:
Pear
Weight:
150lbs
I rented this for a party in Las Vegas, and ended up wearing different dress. This dress looks cute, but it is really, really short. I couldn't have danced in this without my whole behind showing - heck I could barely walk without the walking motion kicking the dress up and showing my backside. My waist is 27.5 and the size 6 was tight at the waist. After dinner it was worse, but it did look nice on. Size up for sure!
Browse Kristin's reviews
Carlee
Peferct for petite girls
April 30th, 2019
Carlee
Size worn:
0
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
0
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
32C
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
98lbs
Like most E&J dresses, this style ran on the smaller side-which is why I like this designer, since I'm so petite (my measurements are about 32/23/31) I wore a 0 and it fit like a glove (was slightly tight in the waist when sitting- but fit more comfortably without a bra). I'm just under 100lbs so finding dresses that fit right is often difficult. At 5'2 this dress hit about mid thigh for me, but with the flirty flare of the dress it felt a little shorter than that (wore Nike pros underneath for my own comfort). Beautiful deep teal color. Loved the subtle side cut outs. Received tons of compliments all night! Paired with a simple necklace, RTR's Jenny Packham's spring splendor earrings, & RTR's Loeffler Randall's pink envelope clutch.
Browse Carlee's reviews
RTR Member
This was actually my backup dress! Loved the neckline! I sized up from a 10 to a 12!
April 15th, 2019
RTR Member
Size worn:
12
Rented for:
Formal Affair
Usual size:
10
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
36C
Body type:
Pear
Weight:
150lbs
So comfy!
Browse RTR Member's reviews
Laura
Great dress!
October 22nd, 2018
Laura
Size worn:
12
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
8
Height:
5' 2"
Body type:
Full Bust
I sized up based on other reviews, and the fact that I didn't want the cutouts to look unflattering. I'm glad I did - I normally wear an 8, and ordered the 10 & 12. There wasn't that much of a difference between the two sizes, but I went with the 12 just so I would feel more comfortable and relaxed. It's a thick, quality material, and a great color for a fall wedding. I felt very confident in it!
Browse Laura's reviews
RTR Member
SUCH a cute dress
October 16th, 2018
RTR Member
Size worn:
6
Rented for:
Other
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 9"
Bust:
28A
Body type:
Straight & narrow
Weight:
122lbs
The dress fit me perfectly, the material was super comfortable, and I got a lot of sweet comments on how people loved the color and style. Really great dress.
Browse RTR Member's reviews
RTR Member
Cute and fun style!
September 21st, 2018
RTR Member
Size worn:
6
Rented for:
Formal Affair
Usual size:
6
Height:
5' 7"
Bust:
30C
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
180lbs
I ordered this dress for my daughters homecoming dance. It fit perfectly and the openings on the sides gave extra flare. She's tall so she had to make sure to bend appropriately but other than that it was perfect!
Browse RTR Member's reviews
Caitlyn
Beautiful dress!
September 12th, 2018
Caitlyn
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
0
Height:
5' 0"
Bust:
32D
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
108lbs
This dress fit like a glove! The cut outs were sexy and the teal color was gorgeous. I loved that I didn't have to wear a bra, I just wore pasties. It was super fun to dance in. I would rent it again.
Browse Caitlyn's reviews
Myra
Great dress
July 1st, 2018
Myra
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Formal Affair
Usual size:
0
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
32DD
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
108lbs
My daughter wore this to her 8th grade formal. Super easy and super cheap and looked great. It was smaller than expected and she had to squeeze into the bigger back up dress but overall very enjoyable.
Browse Myra's reviews
Linnea
Light and comfortable
June 24th, 2018
Linnea
Size worn:
2
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 3"
Bust:
28B
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
120lbs
I wore this for an outdoor wedding and it was perfect. It was light enough that I wasn't hot but thick enough I didn't need a bra. It was a little short in the back so I couldn't really bend down but I got lots of compliments and really loved the dress.
Browse Linnea's reviews
Valerie
This dress fit perfectly, was a good length and color. Quality fabric without being too heavy.
June 23rd, 2018
Valerie
Size worn:
4
Rented for:
Formal Affair
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
32C
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
120lbs
Fit well without making the cutout parts look as if it was too tight
Browse Valerie's reviews
Katie
Great graduation dress!
June 17th, 2018
Katie
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Other
Usual size:
0
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
32B
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
120lbs
I got so many compliments on this dress! It definitely runs small, so make sure that you get the back-up size one size up (especially with the slits in the side)! The color is a nice green that is perfect for warm weather, and the dress can be worn without a bra. The material is a bit heavy, but not too hot for summer! I wish I owned this dress
Browse Katie's reviews
Mashari
LOVED the dress.. got so many compliments.
April 11th, 2018
Mashari
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
6
Height:
5' 5"
Def. runs small especially with the cutouts.. I'm originally a 4 and thank goodness I got a size up to a 6. I think I would even had been more comfortable in a 8. The cut outs kind of cut into your side and it appears that you are bigger than what you are. It is also REALLY short, I had to be careful when I bent over because you could see it all... all in all such a great dress though. 5'5 128lbs 34DDD
Browse Mashari's reviews
Janice
Homecoming Dance
April 2nd, 2018
Janice
Size worn:
10
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
8
Height:
5' 5"
Bust:
36B
Body type:
Pear
Weight:
150lbs
Rented this for my daughters homecoming. It was gorgeous on her! Advice is to go one size up as the cut out areas are not forgiving for anyone larger than the Olsen twins!
Browse Janice's reviews
RTR Member
Perfect for dancing the night away!
November 13th, 2017
RTR Member
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
0
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
32B
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
115lbs
Wore this for my 25th birthday and couldn't ask for anything more in a party dress. Ended up having to use backup size 2 as 0 was a little tight; after sizing-up though, it was comfortable enough to dance and dance until the clubs closed, and still flexible enough to chow down on tacos afterward! Many compliments and made my evening all the more unforgettable. (Necklace & earrings also from RTR)
Browse RTR Member's reviews
RTR Member
Perfect Fit
October 20th, 2017
RTR Member
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 4"
Bust:
32A
Body type:
Straight & narrow
Weight:
118lbs
I go between a 2 and 4 in dresses. With this dress I went with a 4 because the zipper sticks and the cut outs would not be flattering if the dress is too tight. Plenty of compliments all night! Perfect for a casual wedding rehearsal.
Browse RTR Member's reviews
RTR Member
super fun wedding dress!
September 25th, 2017
RTR Member
Size worn:
2
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 4"
Bust:
34C
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
110lbs
i wore this to a florida fall wedding. absolutely loved it! the twirl factor was perfect & it was so flattering. i was able to dance & have an awesome time in this adorable dress!
Browse RTR Member's reviews
RTR Member
Loved it!
September 7th, 2017
RTR Member
Size worn:
4
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 7"
Bust:
32D
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
125lbs
Fit perfectly. The cut outs were a little tight so I bulged through it when I was sitting but other than that it was perfect! So many compliments.
Browse RTR Member's reviews
Julie
Cute and bold
August 22nd, 2017
Julie
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Other
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
34D
Body type:
Hourglass
Weight:
118lbs
I rented this dress as my free birthday dress for being an RTR pro member. The color is beautiful in person, and I loved the side cut outs. The top is fitted, so maybe go a size up for your 2nd size as you could spill out of the side cut outs which would not be flattering. I'm a 34 D so I did have to go up a size due to the fitted top of the dress. I would rent this dress again.
Browse Julie's reviews
RTR Member
Fun and flirty
July 25th, 2017
RTR Member
Size worn:
2
Rented for:
Date
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 6"
Bust:
34A
Body type:
Straight & narrow
Weight:
120lbs
Super cute dress. Love the fabric. Normally wear the zero but had to wear the 2 this time. I'm 5'6" and this wasn't too short.
Browse RTR Member's reviews
Cailyn
The color
July 11th, 2017
Cailyn
Size worn:
6
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
6
Height:
5' 5"
Bust:
34C
Body type:
Athletic
Weight:
135lbs
Awesome I loved it
Browse Cailyn 's reviews
Lianna
So cute!
July 3rd, 2017
Lianna
Size worn:
4
Rented for:
Wedding
Usual size:
4
Height:
5' 3"
Bust:
32B
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
135lbs
I love Elizabeth And James dresses, and this one did not disappointed. Rented this for a backyard wedding, and I think it fit perfectly. I've never worn a dress with cutouts before, but these were cutouts were just the right size, and didn't feel inappropriate at all. This dress was the perfect length on me, but I'm quite short, so watch out if you're taller!
Browse Lianna's reviews
Pamela
Fits like a glove!
June 28th, 2017
Pamela
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 9"
Bust:
32A
Body type:
Straight & narrow
The color, the details, the fit- I absolutely love this dress and would rent again. I received so many compliments, I would even buy it! Perfect dress for a cocktail party! I wore with block tan heels.
Browse Pamela's reviews
Jessica
I loved this dress! Beautiful bold solid color and is easy to accessorize. Lots of compliments!
June 17th, 2017
Jessica
Size worn:
2
Rented for:
Party
Usual size:
2
Height:
5' 2"
Bust:
34B
Body type:
Petite
Weight:
120lbs
It is so flattering because it is snug in all the right places and flares out for a beautiful silhouette line. I felt great in it! It's a gorgeous color and the cutouts are trendy but not too revealing. The size 2 and 4 were pretty close but I felt the 4 was a little too long. The only issue I had was that the hemline folded over in one spot and hung down a bit lower so I had to keep trying to fold it back a few times. (Maybe ironing it would have helped it stay.)
Browse Jessica's reviews
Aimee
So thankful we found this dress on RTR!!
June 8th, 2017
Aimee
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Other
We rented this dress for my daughter's 8th grade dance. We had been to every mall, store and online site until it dawned on me to go to RTR. We got this dress for a fraction of the cost if we had bought one and it arrived on time (actually a day early) which was great so she could try it on and with all the accessories and shoes before the big night. The color is stunning! She got so many compliments on it. I was concerned about the side cut outs but they were very tasteful and not too flashy at all. Even her father approved!! ;) We had to go out of town the next day, so I just brought the package with me and found the nearest UPS, walked in and the guy immediately took it from me and I was on my way!! The process couldn't have been easier or more seamless!! I will never forget this option ever again in the future when looking for the perfect dress for future events. One side note - the dress runs extremely small! My daughter normally wears and size 2 and the size 4 was snug, but she got away with it. She probably could have worn a size 6. Regardless we were VERY satisfied with our selection and the whole process in general. Thank you RTR!!!! -A Relieved and Extremely Satisfied Mother
Browse Aimee's reviews

Here to brighten up your inbox.

Emails are the fastest way to learn about new styles, sales, and more.